Can't Let Him Die

Newspaper of the time reporting the accident

(Translated and compiled by Saya)

24: Anonymous 2006/10/15(Sun) 02:09:41 ID:lLO+L+yO0

Tokaimura criticality accident, triggered by JCO
Tokaimura nuclear accident in 1999
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Tokaimura_nuclear_accident 
The worst civilian nuclear radiation accident in Japan prior to the Fukushima Daiichi nuclear disaster of 2011.

969 :Anonymous:2006/10/15(日) 01:53:32 ID:yo9f4S3g0
>>960
From what I heard, the workers's bodies were severely damaged by neutron
and lost all regenerative ability

The report spoke of necrosis in some parts of the bodies and they died of heart attacks?

981 :Anonymous:2006/10/15(Sun) 01:55:08 ID:LRvDvToC0
>>969
I saw the pictures.

His body was a total wreck but he was still alive.
Really horrible...

A black-and-white photo of the faces of one of the victims in the course of his treatment:
*WARNING contains graphic image* 
http://siustoreroom.blogspot.com/2018/09/tokaimura-accident-victim.html

28: Anonymous: 2006/10/15(Sun) 12:54:51 ID:iyomPQM50
>>24
Everyone would agree that they would rather die than suffer this way.

Right after the exposure to radiation, he had some blisters, but otherwise he looked normal.
But being exposed to high radiation doses shatter your DNA and as a result your body stops generating new cells.
The brain and heart cells have slower metabolism, so they are the last ones to be affected by radiation damage.
So even though your body is ruined beyond repair, you are still fully conscious, and since your heart is still working you stay alive.

They injected a large dosage of morphine - beyond the limit of what a human body can normally endure - into his body, but it had no effect on him.
Everyday, he was given litres after litres of blood transfusion and had 2 to 3 kg of diarrhea (his internal organs were dissolving and coming out of his body as fluids).
His heart had been beating as fast as someone who is doing the 100 metre sprint, ever since the accident.

It meant the modern medical science had advanced to the point that it could keep someone in such a condition alive, but that wasn't the sole reason why his life was prolonged.
He was regarded as a "rare case" and became the object of study, falling prey to eager scientists and researchers, and because those people kept flocking in from all over the world to observe him, they couldn't let him die even if they wanted to.

When I think about how it was all caused by the sloppy supervision, I can't help but feel human beings are by far scarier than any paranormal beings.
Those who had been irradiated cannot even be allowed to be laid in rest in ordinary graves. I can only wish them R.I.P.



----------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Below is a snippet of the documentary that contains a brief description of the accident and also interviews given by the doctor and nurses who cared for Mr. Ouchi:



The same documentary in full length with English subtitles:


The transcript of the video:
http://siustoreroom.blogspot.com/2018/09/tokaimura-criticality-accident-1999.html
The radiation damage also appeared on the surface of his body. About a week after the accident, scars from removing surgical tape became no longer able to heal.
"At first, we used surgical tape as usual. However, it became more and more frequent that his skin was ripped off along with the removed tape. Eventually, we couldn't use surgical tape anymore."
Healthy skin cells divide rapidly and new cells replace old ones. However, in Ouchi's irradiated skin, new cells were no longer generated. His old skin was falling off. Intense pain in his skin. The battle against infection. He had developed fluid retention in his lungs and he began to experience difficulty in breathing.
These are Ouchi's words in his nursing records.
(I can't stand it!)
(I wanna go home!)
(Stop it!)
(Mom!)
The medical team considered putting him on a respirator to help him breathe easier. That meant he would become unable to have conversations with his family. Ouchi talked to his wife who visited him.
"At that time, Mr. Ouchi was probably feeling weariness and heaviness, and he seemed to need to gather strength just to speak. In spite of that, he was smiling slightly and said to his wife 'I love you' in a tender tone. Seeing that kind of scenes made our hearts ache. It was true that nobody knew for sure what would happen to him, but we were able to imagine that his condition would get worse and worse. I guess he himself was also aware of that. In that situation, he told his family of his love. I wonder how he felt when he said to his wife 'I love you.' I think it was a heartwarming moment, but ... I don't know what to say ... I think his words represented what he wanted to tell his family."

----------------------------------------------------------------------------------
20:Anonymous: 2012/8/15/ 21:06:12 : p1Jwnbn1zY

One nurse who cared for Mr. Ouchi said that all of his skin completely fell off, and his whole body had to be soaked in silver nitrate solution* for disinfection, and to her the whole scene was like "Hell on Earth."
If this kind of facts became more widely known, I suspect there would be no one left who would approve of nuclear power plants.
*Danger of silver nitrate (pdf)
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------

WARNING: The article linked below contains GRAPHIC IMAGES at the bottom
Hisashi Ouchi, the Victim of Beyond Fatal Radiation Kept Alive for 83 Days Against His Will
Hisashi Ouchi was one of the technicians working at a facility operated by JCO (formerly Japanese Nuclear Fuel Conversion Co.) in Tokai of Ibaraki Perfecture. He is one of the two fatalities of Tokaimura nuclear accident that exposed him to, perhaps, the highest amount of radiation any human had exposed so far. The ethical value of his prolonged treatment and efforts to keep him alive, that lasted for almost three months despite his wishes and the pain he had to endure, was questioned and the efforts received criticism.

Comments

Shiawase said…
Events such as this truly make me realize that fact is scarier than fiction. History chronicles some of the most horrible experiences, no amount of horror tales can match. I feel so heartbroken.
Mr. Ouchi’s condition reminded me of Alessa in the Silent Hill movie.
Violet said…
this is just sad. humans really are the true monsters.
CreanJinSung said…
Keeping someone alive but in pain just to learn something is considered immoral but there are scientific discoveries that happened because of immorality. It's really hard for me to think because I always try to not be biased. I have a weird brain.
Gabe said…
I forgot where I read about this but there's an article that states it's actually his family that wanted to keep him alive?
allucinator said…
Reminds me of how Americans let Ishii Shirō (石井 四郎) get away because of his "research" in Unit 731.
Yukari said…
This is really heartbreaking. That poor man. His story reminds me of that of Alexis St. Martin - only even worse.
George V said…
Very Sad. They should have honored his wishes.
Haem said…
This is a very sad story but also very disturbing by the fact that is real. There's a lot of cases where people has to endure the worst so doctors and scientists can make investigations that could help other people in the future, but doing it at the cost of other people's suffer, makes it a complicated topic.

Wish you a nice week Saya, take care and stay safe because of the typhoon.
Unknown said…
Wasnt there a rule about this or smt in terms of scientific research whereas we are not allowed to dissect living beings?
Mon said…
I thought of Alessa from Silent Hill too... But reality proved even worse than fiction in this case!
Mon said…
I remember reading about this incident some time ago; and it was (and still is) one of the most sad and disturbing things I've ever seen... that poor man, asking to be allowed to die and be at peace - but no one honoring his wishes. He was made to live a fate worse than death; to live suffering and studied like a lab rat. Rest in peace, Ouchi-san.
Awww sorry to have made you feel heartbroken! It is a really sad story!
Very true, my dear Mon!
I know... :( But you and I are angels! XD
I know what you mean, dear.

It's great you have an unbiased mind.
At the same time though, we have to imagine this sort of thing happening to us or to our loved ones.

I am reminded of a discussion we once had at school, about whether capital punishment is right or wrong.

The teacher said to us that it is all very well to be calm and discuss intellectually about advantages of capital punishment, but imagine if we ourselves are falsely accused and get to be on the receiving end of the capital punishment. Because in the past, there were real instances where people did get executed on false charges, so theoretically it can happen to anyone.

We can only say this whole experiment had some positive outcomes because we think this sort of thing only ever happens to "other people" and not to us. Don't you think so?
His family of course wanted him to get better and prayed he would get over the illness, and the doctors told them they were doing everything they could to bring him back to full health, which wasn't entirely a lie. But we suspect they had other agendas too.
Oh! The notorious Unit 731! Perhaps I should write a post about it too.

I first got to know about Unit 731 through a science teacher at school. He told us how the researchers in the unit referred to those unfortunate test subjects as "Logs." The teacher described to us one experiment they did, in which they put some "logs" into a vacuum chamber and observed them until they expired. Really gruesome.

The irony is that the experiments done by Unit 731 ended up helping greatly the advancement of the modern medical science. Very bizarre and disturbing too.
It's the first time I heard of Alexis St. Martin! :D That case is really bizarre too.
I felt sad too, especially when the man said "I love you" to his family :(
When I read the article linked at the bottom of this post, I overlooked the warning and ended up seeing the graphic pictures... Very, very disturbing.

Thank you for wishing me have a nice week, dear Haem, I wish the same for you! :D <3 Unfortunately, another typhoon is coming this weekend... I wonder what's happening to the climate all over the world?? But thank you again for your kind wishes!
I don't know dear, but I am sure dissecting living human beings isn't permitted. However, those doctors were doing this under the pretext of nursing the man back to health.
Is that so? Curiously, not many people know about this incident, even in Japan. I hope people don't ever forget about it, and hope this post can help to make it stay in our memories.
CreanJinSung said…
I was hospitalized just last year and couldn't weigh in on any decisions because I was unconscious. Only my family and the doctors made the decisions. It's not like the same as your post but when I learned of what they did, none of them considered if I wanted those. But since I am well now, I guess they were correct.
Gabriel said…
I had read some articles about this case previously and it is indeed a very sad story, the poor man did nothing to warrant such suffering. The worst part is how the scientists/doctors said they were trying to help him, but it is pretty blatant that they just wanted to use a rare opportunity to study the effects of fatal radiation poisoning.
I can only pray that he found peace, and that this kind of thing never happens again! Even if I feel like unethical experiments are, sadly, always being conducted somewhere in the world :/

Nonetheless, thanks a lot for this post! Take care
allucinator said…
I have read about it in some horror site (I forgot my source.)

Then somewhere in YouTube, a movie somewhat appeared on a list of related videos; the title is "The Men behind the Sun". It's a movie about the secretive Unit 731. The experiments are depicted well in the movie.

The video link: https://youtube.com/watch?v=nblC28Ivdks
Oh no! I should be more patriotic and scold you for bringing up the subject! XD I really can't watch torture scenes. But thank you for the link! It might appeal to my other blog readers! :D
The story is indeed absolutely horrifying :(

I hope we find a way to abolish all nuclear power plants in the world.

Thank you for your comment! Have a nice day and take care <3
Oh dear, are you OK now?? Were you sick or got hurt in some way? I hope nothing is wrong with you now!
Cookie Chan said…
I understand why you people are angry at the doctors. However, watching the whole documentary, I need to say certain things:

a) His family wanted the doctors to continue the treatment, as they still hoped he could make it (it says so on 35:00 of the video). His family also approved of the doctors giving him experimental medicine.
b) The doctors and nurses were really trying to save him. They were moved by the love of his family and wanted to do it for them and for him. If you see the way they talk about the whole story, you can see they were really trying their best, day and night.
c) Not a single thing is mentioned about him being a guinea pig (his quote about that isn't mentioned either). Now, I understand that some things from this case might have been conveniently ''not mentioned'' in the video, but come on. Even if some of them were doing it for research, most of them were really trying to save him. Humans aren't that bad, and certainly not all of them. These people are humans, not monsters.

From the comments of the video, I also picked up that it was illegal to euthanise a patient in Japan, at least at that time. That includes not bringing him back after his heart stopped (unless the family agreed to that, which they hadn't at the time). Yes, I understand that sometimes the law is unethical, but killing him on purpose would be big trouble for the doctors, the nurses and their families. That means, they were bound both by law and by his family's will to continue.

So please, don't curse these people. They hoped, they tried their best and they failed. They are humans who were desperately trying to save someone, to win a battle against death, even if the odds were against them. I can't imagine how they felt. Some of them do mention they feel guilty for not giving up sooner, but can we blame them for not giving up saving someone's life?
Lynne said…
that looks.. ouchie
Hemu said…
Just remember one thing, good and bad is just the side of the same coin. To some, this deed was inhumane, to some others, this deed was necessary for progress to help if there were any future victim. I feel sorry for anyone who were involved in this tragedy, either they're the victim, medical officers, and etc
CreanJinSung said…
I wasn't saying I had negative feelings about it. I just know it's hard to make decisions on these kinds of things. The ends justifies the means as they say. So that's why it becomes an ethical situation thinking about it now, in my opinion, because he didn't "get better"
Cookie Chan said…
sorry, i meant to post this as a general comment, not as a reply. not very used to blogs. my bad
DjRandom said…
seems like the full documentary is taken down :(

I can only find this playlist
https://www.youtube.com/playlist?list=PL65638A5DF41C59B2

hope it's the same
Anon said…
This story makes me so sad each time I encounter it.. same as for the radium (?) girls. Greed and laziness are a lethal combination.
DjRandom said…
alright I'd managed to find the full documentary (without subtitle) from 2 sites:

https://vimeo.com/114331256
and
https://www.nicovideo.jp/watch/sm31313466
Cheer up dear! Just pray for him to rest in peace.
Hi DjRandom, thank you very much for those links! :D
Vedanth Kamath said…
I don't sleep with my blanket,I only use it during chilly cold winters and rainy or else not.i tried it but even after one week and after one year nothing happened,this is not a true story.